Top Italian Restaurants in Bergen County, NJ
54 businesses · 52 ranked · 20 towns with a board
As of November 2026, BergenHub's county-wide leaderboard for italian restaurants in Bergen County, NJ is topped by Amalfi Italian Specialities, followed by GoodFellas Restaurant at #2 and Volares at #3. Positions are ordered by Google rating and review count.
Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.
- 1
Amalfi Italian Specialities
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.930+ reviews
- 2
GoodFellas Restaurant
Italian restaurant · garfield
4.7500+ reviews
- 3
Volares
Italian restaurant · rutherford
4.7300+ reviews
- 4
Pancetta Kitchen & Wine Bar
Italian restaurant · teaneck
4.7300+ reviews
- 5
Vinnie's Mootz
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.7300+ reviews
- 6
BV Tuscany Restaurant
Italian restaurant · teaneck
4.7300+ reviews
- 7
Lassoni
Italian restaurant · north arlington
4.61000+ reviews
- 8
Gelone
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.6500+ reviews
- 9
Roma
Italian restaurant · north arlington
4.6500+ reviews
- 10
Michael's Riverside
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.6500+ reviews
- 11
Luka's Italian Cuisine
Italian restaurant · bogota
4.6500+ reviews
- 12
Song' E Napule Rutherford
Italian restaurant · rutherford
4.6500+ reviews
- 13
Amarone
Italian restaurant · teaneck
4.6500+ reviews
- 14
Suprema
Italian restaurant · rutherford
4.6500+ reviews
- 15
Casa Giuseppe
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.6300+ reviews
- 16
I Gemelli
Italian restaurant · south hackensack
4.6300+ reviews
- 17
Fat Bastard and Son's Restaurant
Italian restaurant · south hackensack
4.6100+ reviews
- 18
J&S Pork Store
Italian restaurant · lodi
4.6100+ reviews
- 19
Rosolini
Italian restaurant · edgewater
4.6100+ reviews
- 20
Wallington Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant
Italian restaurant · wallington
4.630+ reviews
- 21
Fiorentini Restaurant
Italian restaurant · rutherford
4.5500+ reviews
- 22
Dante's Italian Restaurant, Private Parties and Catering
Italian restaurant · leonia
4.5300+ reviews
- 23
Osteria Pizzeria Ristorante
Italian restaurant · garfield
4.5300+ reviews
- 24
Justin's
Italian restaurant · wood-ridge
4.5300+ reviews
- 25
Angelo's
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.5300+ reviews
- 26
Taste of Tuscany
Italian restaurant · hackensack
4.5300+ reviews
- 27
Pazza Luna Restaurant & Pizzeria
Italian restaurant · garfield
4.5300+ reviews
- 28
Trattoria Il Cafone
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.5300+ reviews
- 29
Roberto's
Italian restaurant · edgewater
4.5100+ reviews
- 30
Sergio's Missione
Italian restaurant · lodi
4.5100+ reviews
- 31
Vesta Wood-Fired
Italian restaurant · east rutherford
4.41000+ reviews
- 32
Franco's Metro Restaurant, Bar & Pizza of Fort Lee, NJ
Italian restaurant · fort lee
4.4500+ reviews
- 33
Forte Ristorante
Italian restaurant · hackensack
4.4500+ reviews
- 34
Tutto A Modo Mio
Italian restaurant · ridgefield
4.4500+ reviews
- 35
Barcelona's Restaurant & Bar
Italian restaurant · garfield
4.4500+ reviews
- 36
The Big Red Tomato
Italian restaurant · fort lee
4.4500+ reviews
- 37
Grissini
Italian restaurant · englewood cliffs
4.4300+ reviews
- 38
Cafe Italiano
Italian restaurant · englewood cliffs
4.4300+ reviews
- 39
Pietro's Trattoria
Italian restaurant · lyndhurst
4.4100+ reviews
- 40
Trattoria Carpaccio
Italian restaurant · englewood
4.4100+ reviews
- 41
Maggiano's Little Italy
Italian restaurant · hackensack
4.31000+ reviews
- 42
Paisano's
Italian restaurant · rutherford
4.31000+ reviews
- 43
Giovanni's Bicycle Club Restaurant & Pizzeria
Italian restaurant · englewood cliffs
4.3500+ reviews
- 44
In Napoli Italian Restaurant & Banquet Hall
Italian restaurant · fort lee
4.3500+ reviews
- 45
Dominick's Restaurant & Bar - Al Di La Caterers
Italian restaurant · east rutherford
4.3500+ reviews
- 46
Bensi
Italian restaurant · hasbrouck heights
4.3300+ reviews
- 47
Carpaccio
Italian restaurant · east rutherford
4.2500+ reviews
- 48
Luigi's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Italian restaurant · ridgefield park
4.1100+ reviews
- 49
Mozzarella Bar
Italian restaurant · east rutherford
4.0500+ reviews
- 50
Red, White and Pasta
Italian restaurant · englewood
4.0100+ reviews
- 51
Gianni D's
Italian restaurant · englewood cliffs
3.7< 30 reviews
- 52
Eatalia Joy
Northern Italian restaurant · east rutherford
2.130+ reviews