Suprema

Review quality analysis

Computed from 17 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar italian restaurant near Rutherford.

• Sonoma Bistro
  1000+ reviewsBistro
• Paisano's
  1000+ reviewsItalian
• Fiorentini Restaurant
  500+ reviewsItalian
• Volares
  300+ reviewsItalian
• Matera's Italian Market
  300+ reviewsDeli

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 30, 2026

  We always love going to Rutherford it has plenty of restaurants, first time coming over here! My family love the place! Food is very good and prepared well! Our son who is a toddler is a very picky eater, he really enjoyed his meal! The atmosphere is great music playing and families enjoying themselves! Definitely will be going to this spot again. Making it a date night since it is BYOB!<br>Service really is on point! The manager was on the floor making sure everyone was good and is very to attentive to everyone eatingand the staff!

  Owner response · Sep 1, 2026

  Hi Martin, Thank you so much for this amazing review! We are so happy to hear that your family had such a great first experience at Suprema, and that your little one enjoyed his meal. That means so much to us! We are also glad you felt well taken care of. Dan will be so happy to hear your kinds words. We really try to make sure every guest feels welcomed and taken care of from the moment they walk in. Thank you again for choosing us, and we can't wait to have you and your family back for another

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 25, 2026

  Went for lunch here. Shared the shrimp appetizer with my wife. 4 jumbo shrimp in a creamy sauce with calabrian peppers. Very tasty with a nice kick. Very good.<br>I had the prosciutto sandwich and my wife had a grilled chicken BLT. Both were excellent!!<br>Prices were a little high and they do add a 3% service fee, but overall this was a very good lunch and I would come back

  Owner response · Aug 30, 2026

  Hi Michael, thank you so much for the wonderful review! We are so happy you and your wife enjoyed your lunch with us. We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and we are glad to hear that you would come back! <br><br>To clarify, the 3% mentioned service fee is a credit card processing fee. We pass along the processing cost when a credit card is used, while there is no additional fee when paying with cash. Thank you again for dining with us, and we hope to see you again so

• GGoogle reviewer

  Aug 18, 2026

  I hosted a baby shower for near 50 people at Suprema and honestly cannot say enough wonderful things about the entire experience. From the very start (planning) to the end of the party, everything was perfect.<br>The venue was beautiful, welcoming and the perfect setting for our celebration. The staff and owners went above and beyond, attentive, professional, reassuring, warm and incredibly accommodating. There were two guests with dietary issues and both the owner and staff in charge made sure that those guests were taken care of. (The GF chicken parm was outstanding).<br>The food overall was excellent. Everything was delicious and exceeded my expectations, especially when catering to a large crowd. Several guests came to me to express how delicious their meal was.<br>I would wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant for any special occasion. I couldn't be happier that I chose this restaurant will do so again in the future.

  Owner response · Aug 23, 2026

  Hi Mary, Thank you so much for this incredibly kind review! It was truly our pleasure to host your daughter's baby shower, and we're so happy you chose Suprema for such a special celebration. <br><br>You were wonderful to work with from the very beginning, and we're so glad we could help make the day everything you hoped it would be. It was important to us to make sure all of your guests felt welcomed and taken care of, including those with dietary needs. <br><br>Hearing that you and your guests

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 18, 2026

  Service was Good <br>Foods was pretty bad I say...<br>We used to came here before they done the renovation and change the menu. The food was really great back then.<br>Haven't been here for a long time and we missed this place, seeing it they done a beautiful renovation it got us so excited to dine in here again. But unfortunately Now it's NO GOOD.<br>And there was 3% fee [Idk what kinda fee] in our bill & not including tipping [they demand cash tips, not directly, but they wrote on the check book ]<br><br>Appetizer was packed with salt and the entree was not enough salt can't get it right.<br><br>Unfortunately...<br>Good by Suprema

  Owner response · Aug 23, 2026

  Hi SimpliCity, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We're sorry to hear that your recent experience did not live up to the visits you remember, especially after returning to see our renovation.<br><br>We're glad to hear that the service was good, but we're disappointed that the food did not meet your expectations. We take feedback about seasoning and consistency seriously and will certainly share your comments with our kitchen team. We do wish you had mentioned your concerns to

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 16, 2026

  Delicious food and dessert very good environment for big groups or big families and special place to celebrate birthday and anniversary

  Owner response · Aug 23, 2026

  Hi Hugo, Thank you so much for the wonderful 5-star review! We're so happy you enjoyed the food, dessert, and atmosphere. It means so much to us that you chose Suprema for your special celebrations, and we hope to welcome you back again soon!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 9, 2026

  First off our waitress was the sweetest most pleasant young lady. She made our dining experience more enjoyable. The food is amazing albeit I wish they would add some more choices such as steak. The appetizers we had were the lemon shrimp and ricotta and bruschetta dip. Those were both a meal alone. For dinner, my husband had spaghetti carbonara which is prepared the way it is supposed to be and I had the stuffed salmon. It was absolutely the best salmon I've ever had.

  Owner response · Aug 16, 2026

  Hi Maria! It was so nice meeting you and your husband Saturday night! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a wonderful review. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your meal and experience at Suprema. We will be sure to share your kind words with your server!<br><br>We rotate our specials every 2 weeks and we do offer steak specials from time to time. Our current specials are always posted on Facebook and instagram, and you're always welcome to call the restaurant to see what