Bergen County SealBergenHub

Top Bagel Shops, Delis & Sandwich Shops in Rutherford

4 bagel shops, delis & sandwich shops businesses in Rutherford · 4 ranked · ordered by bid

As of November 2026, BergenHub's leaderboard for bagel shops, delis & sandwich shops in Rutherford, NJ is topped by Matera's Italian Market, followed by Knead A Bagel at #2 and Bagel Supreme | Rutherford at #3. Positions are ordered by Google rating and review count.

Sponsored Ranking

Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.

  1. 1

    Matera's Italian Market

    Deli

    4.7

    300+ reviews

  2. 2

    Knead A Bagel

    Bagel shop

    4.6

    100+ reviews

  3. 3

    Bagel Supreme | Rutherford

    Bagel shop

    4.2

    500+ reviews

  4. 4

    Rutherford Bagels Inc

    Bagel shop

    4.1

    100+ reviews

Rutherford has 747 listed businesses overall. See every Rutherford leaderboard →