Top Bagel Shops, Delis & Sandwich Shops in Rutherford
4 bagel shops, delis & sandwich shops businesses in Rutherford · 4 ranked · ordered by bid
As of November 2026, BergenHub's leaderboard for bagel shops, delis & sandwich shops in Rutherford, NJ is topped by Matera's Italian Market, followed by Knead A Bagel at #2 and Bagel Supreme | Rutherford at #3. Positions are ordered by Google rating and review count.
Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.
- 1
Matera's Italian Market
Deli · 72 Park Ave
4.7300+ reviews
- 2
Knead A Bagel
Bagel shop · 177 Park Ave
4.6100+ reviews
- 3
Bagel Supreme | Rutherford
Bagel shop · 284 Park Ave
4.2500+ reviews
- 4
Rutherford Bagels Inc
Bagel shop · 335 Union Ave
4.1100+ reviews
More Food & Dining in Rutherford
- American Restaurants2
- Bakeries8
- Burger Restaurants1
- Cafés & Coffee Shops14
- Chicken Restaurants1
- Chinese Restaurants2
- Fast Food, Takeout & Delivery1
- Ice Cream & Dessert Shops3
- Italian Restaurants5
- Japanese Restaurants2
- Juice & Bubble Tea Shop1
- Korean Restaurants1
- Mexican Restaurants2
- Pizza Restaurants5
- Restaurants21
- Sushi Restaurants1
Rutherford has 747 listed businesses overall. See every Rutherford leaderboard →