Bergen County SealBergenHub
Ice Cream Charlie's
🥈#2 Best Ice Cream & Dessert in Rutherford, NJGet Award

Ice Cream Charlie's

4.6
300+ reviews
Food & DiningIce cream shopIce Cream & Dessert
(201) 939-8133Directions
$0.00 raised this season·currently #2 in Rutherford·next bid +$1.00 leaderboard value to take #1·$0.00 behind #1

200 Park Ave

Cozy mom-&-pop ice cream shop offering generous scoops, frozen yogurt & ice cream cakes.

Sponsored Ranking

Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.

In Rutherford

#42 / Food

View category →

In Rutherford overall

#287 of all businesses

Ice Cream & Dessert

#2 in town

Composite score

1 / 100

rating · quality · popularity

Review quality analysis

Computed from 14 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Positive sentiment29%
Owner responsiveness0%
Negative signal21%
Sentiment balance44%

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar ice cream & dessert near Rutherford.

Customer reviews

Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.

See all on Google →
Checking your account…
  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 25, 2026

    Great little private ice cream shop. Love it!

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 23, 2026

    The ice cream was overpriced and was not sweet and wasn't worth the money and then on top of all of that they don't take credit card. You have to have cash.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 21, 2026

    This is my favorite local spot for real ice cream. I love coming here with my partner for dessert. I don't usually like chocolate ice cream, but I love theirs!<br><br>But, I will say, I am very disappointed in their vegan flavors. I took my sisters here while they were visiting since I knew this place had vegan options, and I wanted to share my favorite local spot. The vegan raspberry ice cream with chocolate chips tasted like rancid sour milk. None of us could stomach a full bite. I tried to call the store about the issue right after we realized it was expired but there was no answer unfortunately even though the store was still open.<br><br>So, this place is good for real ice cream, but if you need vegan or gluten free options I strongly suggest you go elsewhere.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Aug 9, 2026

    Rating only — no comment.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Jul 11, 2026

    Rating only — no comment.

  • GGoogle reviewer
    Local Guide
    Jul 4, 2026

    Been coming here since I was in elementary school and the quality hasn't dropped! Thanks for making my cheat days sweeter <3

Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.