240 Paterson Ave Store 2
Custom bake shop for cakes, cupcakes, cake pops and sugar cookies. We also offer classes and parties.
Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.
In East Rutherford
#106 / Food
View category →
In East Rutherford overall
#392 of all businesses
Bakery
#11 in town
Review quality analysis
Computed from 6 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).
What customers mention
Nearby similar stores
Google's picks for similar bakery near East Rutherford.
Customer reviews
Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.
- GGoogle reviewerJan 22, 2026
I truly cannot say enough amazing things about Steph's Baking Boutique -- they were an absolute highlight of both my baby shower and my sister's engagement party! From the very first bite, it was clear that this bakery simply can't be beat.<br><br>Everything was not only stunningly beautiful but unbelievably delicious. You can taste the love, care, and talent that Steph pours into every single creation. Our guests were raving nonstop, going back for seconds (and thirds!), and asking where everything came from. It was hands-down one of the most talked-about parts of both celebrations.<br><br>Steph was an absolute dream to work with -- kind, professional, creative, and so passionate about what she does. She truly helped make our special moments even sweeter, and we are so grateful.<br><br>If you're looking for a bakery that will exceed every expectation and leave a lasting impression, Steph's Baking Boutique is it. We love you, Steph, and will be recommending you forever!
- GGoogle reviewerLocal GuideJan 3, 2026
Ordered 100+ cookies and a cake from Steph. She communicated regularly via email and did create and drop off our items with out any issue. The cookies tasted just okay and the cake was teeny tiny for the price we paid. I did call Steph and mention it was tiny in a voicemail but she never called back or even acknowledged. We didn't have a bad experience but it was not a great one, just seemingly okay.
- GGoogle reviewerJan 19, 2024
Rating only — no comment.
- GGoogle reviewerLocal GuideAug 13, 2023
Just had a slice at a kid's b'day party. Amazing. Great cake texture and just the right amount of icing. I'll be getting my next cake here.
Owner response · Sep 7, 2023
Thank you so much! So happy you liked it.
- GGoogle reviewerMay 15, 2023
I ordered two cakes from Steph's for my sister's graduation party, and they came out perfect! All of her friends and family were in love with these cakes. Beautiful presentation, decadent taste, and just the right consistency. I highly recommend Steph's for any occasion!
Owner response · Sep 7, 2023
Thank you so much! I'm so glad everyone liked them.
- GGoogle reviewerFeb 19, 2023
I ordered a pull apart cupcake for my daughters birthday party. Steph did a great job. It looked even better than the picture I had sent her and it tasted delicious! I will definitely be ordering from here next time I need a cake or cupcakes!!
Owner response · Sep 7, 2023
Thank you so much! I'm glad you liked them.
Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.