Paul M. Rothenberg, M.D. - Orthopaedic Surgeon
935 River Rd
Dr. Paul Rothenberg, M.D., is a Board Certified orthopedic surgeon in New Jersey specializing in operative and non-operative treatment of sports-related injuries of the shoulder, elbow, knee, and ankle. His expertise includes minimally invasive arthroscopic surgery, cartilage restoration, and shoulder replacement. He has worked with teams like the New York Jets, New York Islanders, and Miami Marlins. A former athlete and Union College football player, Dr. Rothenberg understands the impact of injuries and is passionate about helping patients return to their active lifestyles.
Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.
In Edgewater
#7 / Health
View category →
In Edgewater overall
#17 of all businesses
Orthopedics
#1 in town
Composite score
1 / 100
rating · quality · popularity
Review quality analysis
Computed from 15 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).
Nearby similar stores
Google's picks for similar orthopedics near Edgewater.
Customer reviews
Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.
- GGoogle reviewerSep 2, 2026
It was an amazing experience. They were so Attentive, professional, and So welcoming. The Dr, the staff were excellent! Very very pleased! I would recommend it to anyone! Loved it. Very satisfied!
- GGoogle reviewerSep 2, 2026
Dr Rothenberg is a very excellent surgeon and his care was exceptional. I would definitely recommend Dr. Rothenberg as an orthopedic surgeon
- GGoogle reviewerSep 2, 2026
Dr. Rothenberg and staff were great. Through out my ACL journey they were there step by step. Any questions I had before and after the surgery answered fully, no matter the day. Dr. Rothenberg was comforting towards me and my family. The staff were friendly and efficient when it came intake and scheduling. Overall, I had a great experience and feeling well and healthy.
- GGoogle reviewerSep 2, 2026
Dr Rothenberg was extremely throughout while figuring out what was causing my pain. First he was going in my shoulder that I had already had a replacement in to see if there was an infection but while in there he removed a loose piece which seems to have been what was causing my pain. I am so grateful I don't have to have another surgery. But I would say if you need surgery he's your guy! His bedside manner is excellent and cares about you.
- GGoogle reviewerSep 1, 2026
Rating only — no comment.
- GGoogle reviewerSep 1, 2026
Dr. Paul Rothenberg is a truly exceptional surgeon with a warm and welcoming personality. This was my 6 month follow up after my reverse shoulder replacement surgery. I am a former dancer in my 70's and have had both knees replaced so I am familiar with joint replacement surgeries. I trusted Dr. Rothenberg immediately. He answered all my questions and explained what he would be doing and what I should expect before, during and after the procedure. He made me feel more relaxed and prepared than I had ever been going into surgery. The outcome was better than I could have imagined! My physical therapist who has been in the business for 20 years couldn't get over my range of motion on my very first visit. I continued to make great progress and have regained my full range of motion which I haven't had since my 30's. I have already scheduled an appointment for my other shoulder surgery with Dr. Rothenberg for next summer. I highly recommend him to everyone. You couldn't make a better choice!
Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.