Anthony Fuccilli: Allstate Insurance
230 Stuyvesant Ave
The Anthony Fuccilli Agency helps people realize their dreams through products and services designed to protect them from life's uncertainties and prepare them for their future.
Ordered by owner and customer bids — bought, not earned. BergenHub promotes Bergen County businesses; it doesn't rate service quality.
In Lyndhurst
#43 / Professional
View category →
In Lyndhurst overall
#355 of all businesses
Insurance agency
#7 in town
Composite score
1 / 100
rating · quality · popularity
Review quality analysis
Computed from 15 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).
Nearby similar stores
Google's picks for similar insurance agency near Lyndhurst.
- Anthony Benevenia - State Farm Insurance Agent< 30 reviewsInsurance agency
- Maiello & Manzi Insurance Agency< 30 reviewsInsurance agency
- Farmers Insurance - Alfonso Albunia< 30 reviewsInsurance agency
- Merwin & Paolazzi Insurance Agency< 30 reviewsInsurance agency
- Manzo Insurance< 30 reviewsInsurance agency
Customer reviews
Ratings and comments from Google and BergenHub members, combined into one score. Sign in with a verified-email account to add yours.
- GGoogle reviewerLocal GuideFeb 19, 2026
Unprofessional and Disorganized office. Policy went into cancellation twice because of agent negligence specifically Maria Dacosta. First time the office did not properly request payment in escrow from the Mortgage lender. I went through the whole process and had to personally make the payment in order for the lapse in coverage to not occur. I changed my mailing address to my business mailing address in the bordering state. Maria asked me if the insured home was my primary residence. I confirmed with her that it was. Without following up she then "did research" where she found an old listing of it for rent for a short period of time when in reality I had changed my mind about renting it and currently occupy it for 60% of the time. The policy went into cancellation days after again off of this assumption with no evidence. They are a shady organization. I would stay away for peace of mind and professional treatment.
- GGoogle reviewerDec 27, 2025
Policy just keeps going up every few months and don't get responses
- GGoogle reviewerSep 12, 2025
Very disappointed in this organization. Unprofessional. Terrible customer service, not fair to loyal customers. I very much feel I am NOT in good hands. I called my representative and NEVER get a call back. I have to get a call from random people in the office and none of them can assist me. Currently shopping for a new provider smh.
- GGoogle reviewerMay 7, 2025
The worst service from a very unprofessional woman named Rafaela A. In the Lyndhurst office she may need more education regarding customer service but she is completely lacking in that area. Treated my child's father as if she was annoyed and had better things to do gave him the run around on the why the rate increased by 700 dollars when there have been no accidents. When he asked for a supervisor unfortunately he was not in the office I guess that's why she was acting so abrasive. I also received the same treatment in a separate phone call I will be escalating this since she didn't have the customer services skills needed to diffuse the situation that another sales rep did. I hope they review the phone recording and use her as a what not to do training.
- GGoogle reviewerJan 21, 2025
Excellent service abd experiences sine I have been with Allstate over 30 years
- GGoogle reviewerLocal GuideDec 30, 2024
Maria and Anthony have been caring for me for years. Couldn't be happier. I highly recommend to my friends and family.
Sponsored Ranking. Positions are bought through owner and customer bids, not awarded on quality. BergenHub helps Bergen County businesses get discovered; it does not rate their service.