GoodieBox Bakeshop

Review quality analysis

Computed from 18 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar bakery near Rutherford.

• Erie Coffeeshop & Bakery
  300+ reviewsBakery
• Sweet Avenue Bake Shop
  300+ reviewsVegan
• Polkadot Cake Shop
  100+ reviewsCake shop
• Varrelmann's Bake Shop
  30+ reviewsBakery
• Steph's Baking Boutique LLC
  < 30 reviewsBakery

• GGoogle reviewer

  Aug 15, 2026

  Rating only — no comment.

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jun 6, 2026

  The honey and coconut cakes are yummy, however the slices are expensive. They do not have seating (not a cafe style but more pick up and eat elsewhere). The main issue we had was when ordering a cake for a birthday. We ordered it 4 weeks in advance but they never got in touch with us, they took down our phone # too. We reached out 2 more times but they never contacted us to let us know if they're making the cake or not. Therefore 4 days before the birth date, we decided we to just order from another place. We didn't appreciate how no one reached out to us after ordering in advance.

  Owner response · Jul 8, 2026

  Kinga,<br><br>We greatly appreciate your response. We work hard to exceed expectations and it appears here we could use some improvement on our response time. If no one responded to your inquiry this sounds like a fair and reasonable review. If you would be open to reaching out directly, we would like to make it up to you. Please feel free to email us at info@goodieboxbakeshop.com <br><br>Thank you.<br><br>Carrie- Owner

• GGoogle reviewer

  Apr 4, 2026

  I stopped in for some pastries and ended up leaving with so much more than just something sweet. The macaroons were absolutely delicious, perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and flavorful on the inside. You can really tell they're made with care.<br><br>What truly made my experience, though, was Renee. She was incredibly kind, welcoming, and just radiated such positive energy. She had no idea I was having a really hard day, but her attitude genuinely lifted my spirits more than she probably realizes. It's rare to come across someone who makes that kind of impact in such a simple interaction.<br><br>Between the amazing treats and the even better service, I'll definitely be coming back.<br><br>(P.S) I'm the girl that was sitting in the car!<br><br>Thank you buttercup!

  Owner response · May 9, 2026

  We want to thank you tremendously for taking a moment to share your experience. As the owner, I have been stopped on the street and told how kind Renee. She is an asset to our team. Your kind words I know made her smile and feel appreciated so thank you for this. It is always good to feel your efforts matter. I am elated you loved the macarons from Buttercup, we partner with them because they are the best!<br><br>Thank you for sharing your experience and I look forward to feeding you more sweet

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Mar 29, 2026

  All the guests loved the cake which Carrie baked for us. Sweetness was just the right level. She and her associate go out of the way to help you decide the kind of cake which would be appropriate for the occasion. If I have to summarize in one word. Delicious!!!!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Mar 16, 2026

  I first booked with goodie box for my baby shower.<br>I communicated with Carrie by email and she was very responsive. I showed the theme of the baby shower and she executed, I was mesmerized. Everyone complemented the pastries and they were so delicious.<br>I loved their work so much that I also booked a cake and cupcakes for my husband's birthday a few weeks later and that was phenomenal as well.<br>I can't wait for my next occasion to book with them again

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jan 14, 2026

  Carrie's cakes are the best: moist, light, and flavorful. I ordered cakes from her for my daughter's last 2 birthdays, and am about to order for the 3rd year in a row!