Annamaria's Deli

Review quality analysis

Computed from 11 text reviews using BergenHub's quality scoring (sentiment, owner responsiveness, review depth).

Nearby similar stores

Google's picks for similar bagel, sandwich & deli near East Rutherford.

• Annabella's House of Mozzarella
  1000+ reviewsRestaurant
• Matera's Italian Market
  300+ reviewsDeli
• Uncle Tony's Deli
  100+ reviewsDeli
• Appetizzio's Italian deli
  100+ reviewsDeli
• Legacy Deli & Convenience
  30+ reviewsDeli

• GGoogle reviewer

  Aug 23, 2026

  Came in from out of town, exceptional sandwich. Try a different deli every time. This one is the best I've ever had. Had the Annamaria. I think the magic is that they cut the meat really thin. Nice little patio too. Just amazing.

  Owner response · Aug 30, 2026

  Hey Jamie, thank you so much for the incredible review! Hearing that you try a different deli everywhere you go and consider ours the best sandwich you've ever had means a lot to us. We're so glad you loved the Annamaria, from the thinly sliced meats to the patio experience. We really appreciate you stopping in while you were in town and hope we get to serve you again!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 21, 2026

  Write a positive Google review for Annamaria's Deli based on the following experience:<br><br>I've been biking past this shop for months, and since it shares my name, I finally decided to stop in--and I'm so glad I did! The atmosphere reminds me of the old-school small businesses we used to have in Brooklyn.<br>The menu is huge, and I love that you can choose from four different types of bread; I went with the Semolina. It was great to see such a hardworking team behind the counter, even in such an intimate space. I ordered the "Nonna," which is one of their three vegetarian options. It featured fresh mozzarella, eggplant, artichoke, olive oil, and balsamic, and it was absolute perfection. I'm still dreaming about it! If you're looking for a top-tier Italian sandwich, do yourself a favor and stop by. Bellissima!

  Owner response · Aug 23, 2026

  Hey Anna, thank you so much for this incredible review! We love that you finally decided to stop in after biking past us for months, and even better that Annamaria's shares your name! It means a lot that our little deli brought back memories of those old-school Brooklyn neighborhood shops. Our bread is delivered fresh daily from a Brooklyn bakery that still uses a 100-year-old bread oven, so we're especially happy you enjoyed the semolina. We're so glad you loved the Nonna and appreciated our ha

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Aug 17, 2026

  Rating only — no comment.

  Owner response · Aug 23, 2026

  Hey Chiara, thank you so much for the 5-star review! We truly appreciate your support and are so glad you had a great experience with the food, service, and atmosphere. We look forward to seeing you again soon!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Aug 3, 2026

  Came here after searching for a good italian deli and boy was I happy. This is the kind of italian deli you see now. They got a board of sandwich names and after trying the Andrea with warm Porchetta sliced and stacked nice and thin

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Thank you Lorenzo! We can't wait to see you again soon!!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Jul 28, 2026

  This is THE sandwich spot. Lived in Tristate area for almost my entire life and this place is absolute perfection. Do yourself a favor and give these fine folks all the business you can - they have it figured out.

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Hey IMJ,<br><br>Wow--thank you for such an incredible review! Hearing that you consider us the sandwich spot in the Tri-State area truly means the world to us. We put our heart into every sandwich, and we're grateful for your kind words and recommendation. We can't wait to welcome you back to Annamaria's Deli for another great meal!

• GGoogle reviewer

  Local Guide

  Jul 22, 2026

  I've been coming to this place for years and it gets better every time! I'm determined to eat my way through the whole menu, but if you're a tuna lover like me, I actually do like Italian tuna "the Nono" is my fav

  Owner response · Aug 7, 2026

  Hey Ivy,<br><br>Thank you so much for your continued support over the years! It truly means a lot to hear that each visit keeps getting better. We're honored to be part of your journey through the menu, and we're thrilled that The Nono has become one of your favorites! We appreciate your kind words and recommendations, and we can't wait to welcome you back soon to help you check off even more sandwiches from the list. See you again soon!